kieran-
dodds
photo-
graphy

More things people said on The Guardian about gingers

I read the comments and I liked it.

An edited highlight of the glorious conjecture and outrage from the comments section following the article on The Guardian entitled ‘Ginger Snaps: Portraits of red-heads in Russia and Scotland’ For the original comments see the foot of this post. 

BaldricksBrother 

This suffers from being unengaging. It looks like a high street photographer's promo - free portrait session if you're ginger. Might have been more interesting if everyone was ginger AND had webbed feet or the subjects were people who had dyed their hair ginger because they felt insecure and left out.

Analternative
Couldn't agree less. One picture may be, but a collection like this is wonderful. How similar we all are and yet so different but all unique. People watching but at an intense level. 

Domani

Rubbish, from a proud ginger.

Leidschenman
Well, you bit on the clickbait! 

HandandShrimp

It was news to me that there are rising tensions between Scotland and Russia. Weird comment to add to an otherwise beautiful set of pictures. 

JonFredricks

This is becoming a tiresome photographic trend. A photographer should take portraits of people for who they are, not because of a superficial trait, like hair colour. 
Furthermore, the colour is totally off in these photos. There is too much yellow-green in their hair. 

JDSalinger27


Agree about the colour. Also terribly over processed for my taste.
Some seems literally green about the gills.
But, hey... whatever turns you on. Priestley 
So you'll have no objections to 'Coco Pops' prefacing articles about black people then? 

Blueywest1
Fantastic portraits technically, BUT what great looking people too. They need to be CELEBRATED, not persecuted, especially the kids. 
 

twilightegal 

The Viking influence? 


Mark Norman

Absolutely it is. Russian's are descended from the Rus' people, who are basically a mix of Norsemen (from Scandanavia - re: Vikings) and Mongol/Caucasians from the East. Get The Grade Get The Grade 
I believe "Russia" took it's name from the colour red - were the Russian people originally red heads? 

strangeburdock 


Actually I think it's related to an old term for people from Sweden.. rus, or men who row.. referring to longboats used by the Volga Vikings that made their way across Russia as far as the middle east. The Finnish for Sweden is also related.. 

Ruotsi SouthernStar1010 


Rus = Vikings, the Vikings travelled down the Eastern European rivers and settled in what is now Ukraine mixing over time with the local Slavic tribes. Some Slavs from Ukraine moved to what is now Russia later on.

Mark Norman 
Most definitely you can tell. I think it's mainly in the eyes and also the clothing, but there are small indicators facially too. Very interesting. 


ID9637740

It's interesting that St Andrew is the patron of Scotland and Russia. Are there many redheads in Greece where he's also the patron?




ecclefechan ecclefechan

Why would the patron Saint whose only physical connection is through bought relics influence the colour of a country's citizens hair?
 

ID9637740

Oh dear, I did wonder if anyone would take my post seriously… 

CaroOnline

I believe it's the other way around - the red hair came to Scotland from North Caucasus - now Russia, Georgia and Azerbaijan. Siberian red hair originates from Caucasus too. 


Impr0v

Roy Brian is the most Scottish looking person ever. 

Leslie Cooper

"Stop exoticising me!!”

TwinDutchess


These pictures make my heart sing. My husband is ginger and our four children (including twins) are also ginger. Sometimes sitting outside in the evening just when the light turns shows my family as the most beautiful collection of people ever. It's like they all have a copper and gold fire around their faces..... I couldn't be more proud of them. 

leodensian

I can't imagine I could convince anyone to accompany me to the Photography festival to look at ginger people. So thanks, Guardian, for bringing the ginger people to me.
 

JonFredricks

They can pick whatever subject they want to and I can have whatever opinion about it that I want to. There are dozens of these series on photographic sites and this is the least inspired I've seen, despite having good subjects. That's because these photos are only about the hair, not the person wearing it.
 

shecurmudgeon

Why are all the Russians only from Perm?



ArundelXVI

I imagine because that's where the photographer went for his project, and solicited for subjects, which takes time to arrange. It's not a very mobile operation.
 

Robaire

This is precisely the same as prejudice towards people because of their skin colour. Red hair is genetic and intrinsic to a person's biology and therefore a racial characteristic. It is abhorrent to target an alienate an individual due to their hair type - Imagine if the same criticisms were directed towards those who have other hair colours that characterise their ancestry




sgwnmr

That ginger slave trade and holocaust tho. 

Fartknocker

Vote for kid rock 

The original ‘things people said about the gingers’: http://kierandodds.com/journal/subjects/stories/things-people-said-on-the-guardian-about-gingers

share: